
Indications for Supramalleolar Osteotomy Based on Arthroscopic Findings for Varus Type Ankle Osteoarthritis
Background: Preoperative arthroscopic examinations were carried out in patients with varus deformity among those with osteoarthritis of the ankle caused by malalignment, and to assess the severity of the disease on the basis of the arthroscopic findings, and the associations of these findings with X-ray findings and the indications for supramalleolar osteotomy were evaluated.
Methods: A total of 57 joints in 56 patients were investigated, and the mean follow-up period was 4 years. The proportion of the surface area of the ankle that had become hardened into an eburnation was classified according to a five-grade scale on the basis of preoperative arthroscopy: Grade 1 indicated fibrillation of the articular cartilage alone with no evident eburnation; Grade 2, eburnation was limited to the medial malleolar articular surface; Grade 3, eburnation extended across the medial shoulder of the talus, but covered <25% of the talocrural joint; Grade 4, eburnation covered ≥25% but <50% of the talocrural joint; and Grade 5, eburnation covered ≥50% of the talocrural joint. The surgical procedure used was lateral closing wedge osteotomy, and assessments were carried out using Takakura, et al.’s clinical score and Tanaka, et al.’s radiographic grading system.
Results: Initially, 3 joints were Grade 1, 19 were Grade 2, 15 were Grade 3, 16 were Grade 4, and 4 were Grade 5. Postoperatively, 30 joints were Grade 1, 14 were Grade 2, 7 were Grade 3, 4 were Grade 4, and 2 were Grade 5. Clinical scores showed an improvement from 63.9±11.2 points preoperatively to 81.9±13.2 points postoperatively.
Conclusion: Patients who were classed as Grade 3 or below by preoperative arthroscopy showed improved clinical outcomes and radiographic grades. To assess the proportion of cartilage, that may be affect postoperative outcomes, preoperative arthroscopy should be done prior to the supramalleolar osteotomy.
Naohiro Hio¹*, Atsushi Hasegawa², Satoshi Monden³, Hideo Noguchi⁴, Masanori Taki⁵, and Kenji Takagishi¹