Back to Journal

Journal of Surgical Oncology & Clinical Research

Case Report: Vigil Therapy in Pathology Defined High-Risk Differentiated Thyroid Cancer Compounded by Post Ablation High-Risk Factors

[ ISSN : 3068-0727 ]

Abstract Citation Introduction Case Report Discussion Acknowledgements Disclosure/Conflict of Interest References
Details

Received: 14-Sep-2017

Accepted: 02-Oct-2017

Published: 05-Oct-2017

Minal Barve¹,², Radhika Barve¹, Jennifer Rao¹, Luisa Manning³, Donald D Rao⁴, Ned Adams¹, Neil Senzer¹,³,⁴ and John Nemunaitis¹-⁵*


¹Physician Investigator, Mary Crowley Cancer Research Centers, USA
²Physician Investigator, Texas Oncology, USA
³Physician Investigator, Gradalis Inc, USA
?Scientific Director, Strike Bio, USA
?Physician Investigator & Executive Medical Director, Medical City Dallas Hospital, USA

Corresponding Author:

John Nemunaitis, Physician Investigator & Executive Medical Director, Medical City Dallas Hospital, 12222 Merit Drive, Suite 1500, Dallas, Texas 75251, USA, Tel: 214-658-1964; Fax: 214-658-1992; Email: jnemunaitis@marycrowley.org

Abstract

Thyroglobulin levels ≥50 μg/L following thyroidectomy and I131 ablation correlate with poor prognosis in patients with high risk Differentiated Thyroid Cancer (DTC). We describe a case of a 54 year old woman with differentiated thyroid cancer and high thyroglobulin up to 220 μg/L following thyroidectomy and I131 ablation who demonstrated marked response to a novel immunotherapy involving autologous tumor cell transfected with a GMCSF/bi-shRNA furin expressive plasmid (Vigil). Activity is highlighted by four year disease free survival in correlation with immune activation as measured by ELISPOT assay of peripheral blood mononuclear cell reaction to autologous tumor. Further investigation with Vigil in differentiated thyroid cancer is warranted.

Citation

Minal B, Radhika B, Rao J, Manning L, Rao DD, Adams N, et al. Case Report: Vigil Therapy in Pathology Defined High-Risk Differentiated Thyroid Cancer Compounded by Post Ablation High-Risk Factors. J Surg Oncol Clin Res. 2017; 1(1): 1005.

Introduction

In a recent analysis of 243 patients with high-risk Differentiated Thyroid Cancer (DTC) [1] following thyroidectomy and I131 ablation, thyroglobulin (Tg) levels ≥50 μg/L within 2 years of diagnosis were shown to be a significant predictor for disease persistence with a 97% Positive Predictive Value (PPV) as well as for Progression Free Survival (PFS) [2]. We describe a high-risk DTC patient who, following thyroidectomy and I131ablation, demonstrated persistent Tg > 50 µg/L with no evidence of residual disease by radionuclide scan, CT or regional ultrasound. In view of this incomplete biochemical response, the patient underwent treatment with a novel immune modulating therapy called Vigil [3-7]. Vigil elicited a serological immune response and was followed by stabilization of Tg expression. This patient remains alive with neither visible disease nor evidence of structural or biochemical progression 4 years after treatment initiation.

Case Report

Patient #075 was a 54-year-old asymptomatic woman when, in 2013, she was found to have nodular enlargement of her thyroid gland on routine physical examination. An ultrasound revealed a mass in the left lobe with multiple adjacent enlarged lymph nodes. On 05/11/2013 biopsy showed malignant papillary thyroid carcinoma. She underwent a total thyroidectomy with node dissection. Final pathology revealed a 4 cm papillary carcinoma, follicular variant, replacing the left lobe with metastases to six of seven left regional nodes. Lympho vascular invasion and tumor capsular penetration were present as well as perineural and extra thyroidal extension. Therefore, the tumor was staged IVA (T4N1b) and deemed high risk per the American Thyroid Associated (ATA) Risk Stratification System [8]. She underwent ablative I131 therapy (160 mCi) on 7/31/2013. A head and neck sonogram on 10/30/2013 showed no residual thyroid tissue, however the Tg concentration was 220 µg/L with thyroglobulin antibody < 20 IU/mL (Figure 1). Following thyrogen stimulation she received a second I131injection (4.9 mCi) followed by a diagnostic scan on 3/21/2014, which showed no evidence of residual disease. A follow up sonogram confirmed no evidence of loco regional disease, however her thyroglobulin remained elevated at 77.5 µg/L. Distant metastases were further excluded by CT scan of neck through pelvis. Thyroid hormone therapy was started with TSH stabilization within normal levels. On the basis of the risk attendant to the persistently elevated thyroglobulin following debulking surgery and I131 therapy, Patient #075 elected to participate in a MCCRC phase I study assessing low dose Vigil (1x106 cells/inj) [9].

Figure 1: Correlation of Thyroglobulin Level and ELISPOT Response of Patient #075, a 54 year Female with Stage IV Malignant Papillary Thyroid Cancer Following Surgery/I131 Failure x2 (Time Course of Therapy is Also Shown below Time Line).

The first Vigil dose was administered on 6/16/2014. The immune response was measured by IFN-y ELISPOT assay at baseline before initiation of Vigil and prior to each of the subsequent treatments (Figure 1). All 4 cycles of Vigil were well tolerated without Grade 3 or higher adverse events. The post diagnostic 4.9 mCi 131I scan thyroglobulin of 77.5 µg/L decreased to 17.8 just prior to Vigil and continues to remain stable (range, 14.1-18 μg/L), the most recent being 16.9 μg/L (Figure 1). A positive ELISPOT response (>10 spots/105 MNC’s) was observed within 1 month of Vigil start, persisted at 5 months after the first dose of Vigil but decreased to 6 and 7 spots/105 MNC’s at 7 months. Unfortunately, there is not an adequate amount of non-transfected tumor tissue available to continue further ELISPOT testing. There is still no evidence of disease on follow up CT scans. The patient is now > 4 years from diagnosis.

Discussion

This is a case of a high-risk DTC patient based on surgical and pathological findings elevated to a higher risk status based on an incomplete biochemical response following disease specific therapy. Further, the follicular variant of papillary carcinoma is associated with a significantly higher risk of disease-specific mortality compared to classical papillary carcinoma [10]. The role that Vigil, an autologous tumor/GMCSF-bi-shRNA furin DNA transfected immunotherapy, may be playing in her continued state of well-being with neither overt disease recurrence nor continued rise in Tg levels is suggested by the elicited immune response as measured by IFN-у ELISPOT assay. That this functional assay correlates with survival and time to progression has been shown in a broad range of solid tumors as reported in prior publications [3-7]. Moreover, correlation of immune response induction and clinical benefit has been observed with low dose Vigil (<1x107 cells/inj for minimum of 4 injections) [9]. Further experimental trial testing of Vigil and immune responsiveness of DTC is recommended.

Acknowledgements

We gratefully acknowledge the generous support of the Joe and Jessie Crump Foundation Medical Research Fund, Wilson Charitable Foundation Trust, Million Dollar Roundtable Foundation and Carter Crowley Foundation. The authors would like to acknowledge Michelle Richey and Brenda Marr for their competent and knowledgeable assistance in the preparation of the manuscript. Special thanks to Joe Kuhn, M.D., a good friend to John Nemunaitis who performed this surgery on patient #075 but passed away from cancer prior to publication of this case report.

Disclosure/Conflict of Interest

The following authors are shareholders in Gradalis, Inc. and Strike Bio: Donald D. Rao, Neil Senzer and John Nemunaitis. The authors have no other relevant affiliations or financial involvement with any organization or entity with a financial interest in or financial conflict with the subject matter or materials discussed in the manuscript.

References

1. Pacini F. European consensus for the management of patients with differentiated thyroid carcinoma of the follicular epithelium. Eur J Endocrinol. 2006; 154: 787-803.

2. Piccardo A. Focus on high-risk DTC patients: high postoperative serum thyroglobulin level is a strong predictor of disease persistence and is associated to progression-free survival and overall survival. Clin Nucl Med. 201; 38: 18-24.

3. Oh J, Barve M, Matthews CM, Koon EC, Heffernan TP, Fine B, et al. Phase II study of Vigil(R) DNA engineered immunotherapy as maintenance in advanced stage ovarian cancer. Gynecol Oncol. 2016; 143: 504-510.

4. Ghisoli M, Barve M, Mennel R, Lenarsky C, Horvath S, Wallraven G, et al. Three-year Follow up of GMCSF/bi-shRNA(furin) DNA-transfected Autologous Tumor Immunotherapy (Vigil) in Metastatic Advanced Ewing’s Sarcoma. Mol Ther. 2016; 24: 1478-1483.

5. Senzer N. Phase I trial of “bi-shRNAi(furin)/GMCSF DNA/autologous tumor cell” vaccine (FANG) in advanced cancer. Mol Ther. 2012; 20: 679-686.

6. Senzer N, et al. Long Term Follow Up: Phase I Trial of “bi-shRNA furin/ GMCSF DNA/Autologous Tumor Cell” Immunotherapy (FANG™) in Advanced Cancer. Journal of Vaccines and Vaccination. 2013; 4: 209.

7. Ghisoli M, Rutledge M, Stephens PJ, Mennel R, Barve M, Manley M, et al. Case Report: Immune-mediated Complete Response in a Patient With Recurrent Advanced Ewing Sarcoma (EWS) After Vigil Immunotherapy. J Pediatr Hematol Oncol. 2017; 39: e183-e186.

8. Haugen BR, Alexander EK, Bible KC, Doherty GM, Mandel SJ, Nikiforov YE, et al. 2015 American Thyroid Association Management Guidelines for Adult Patients with Thyroid Nodules and Differentiated Thyroid Cancer: The American Thyroid Association Guidelines Task Force on Thyroid Nodules and Differentiated Thyroid Cancer. Thyroid. 2016; 26: 1-133.

9. Manning L. Assessment of Low Dose Vigil® Engineered Autologous Tumor Cell (EATC) Immunotherapy in Patients with Advanced Solid Tumors. Clinics in Oncology. 2017; 2: 1254.

10. Yu XM, Schneider DF, Leverson G, Chen H, Sippel RS. Follicular variant of papillary thyroid carcinoma is a unique clinical entity: a population-based study of 10,740 cases. Thyroid. 2013; 23: 1263-1268.

Other Articles

Article Image 1

Merkel Cell Carcinoma of the Inguinal Lymph Node in the Absence of a Primary Site: A New Case Report and Literature Review

Introduction: Merkel Cell Carcinoma (MCC) is a rare and aggressive neuroendocrine tumor of the skin. The main characteristics are frequent local recurrences and disseminations to regional lymph nodes and distant organs. MCC within the lymph nodes in the absence of a primary site is rare and few cases have been reported by the literature.

Case Report: We report a case of MCC presenting as a painless mass in the left inguinal area for 6 months in a 48-year-old women. The histopathology of the excised lesion revealed a poorly differentiated basophilic small cell tumor. The immunohistochemical study finding the diagnosis of a metastatic MCC. Despite extensive clinical and radiological investigation, we failed to identify the origin of the tumor.

Conclusion: Rare cases of MCC confined to a lymph node without an apparent primary site have been reported. We report a new case of MCC in the inguinal lymph node without identification of the primary site.

Mohamed Amine Azami¹, Othman Lahbali¹, Iliass El Alami², Zouidia F¹, and Mahassini N¹*


Article Image 1

Can be Seroma a normal event in Breast Surgery? Analysis from Survey in Plastic Surgery Safety Conference

Introduction: Breast Surgery especially augmentation is a common procedure worldwide. Literature reports relationship between chronic seroma and Anaplastic Large Cell Lymphoma (ALCL) has increased. Recently we reported the first case in Mexico. Risk factors should be evaluated. Seroma seems to be a common event after this type of surgery. Chronic seroma seems to be most common symptom in ALCL

Methods: Survey was conducted during Security Conference in breast implant augmentation, to know features as breast implants ratio in private practice of plastic surgeons, type of implant used, surgical technique and complications. Descriptive statistics including measures of central tendency were estimated.

Results: 72 members answered the survey. Implant placement is a procedure performed frequently. Preference is textured implants with volume between 300cc and 360cc. The most common complication was seroma. Reoperation was related with capsular contracture and patient no satisfaction.

Discussion: Seroma is a common complication. Possible relation with biofilm and Anaplastic Large Cell Lymphoma should be evaluated. Lymphoma is not a common finding in breast implant but long lasting infection can be considered as risk factor. Measures to prevent seroma should be proposed. Analysis from the type of textured in the coverage of the implant should be evaluated.

Conclusion: This information allows us to take further action to direct sessions, courses and conferences, to decrease the frequency of seroma and prevent complications being one of the procedures most frequently performed by the membership.

Guillermo Ramos-Gallardo¹,², Carlos-Guillermo Oaxaca-Escobar¹, Jesus Cuenca Pardo¹, Livia Contreras-Bulnes¹, Eugenio Rodríguez-Olivares³, Imelda Díaz-Ruiz⁴, and Mauricio Alejandro García-López⁴*


Article Image 1

Percentage of Surgical Lung Cancers Missed by National Screening Criteria

Background: The US Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) recommends screening for smokers based on age, pack-years of smoking, and years since past smokers quit (quit-time). Previous studies determined low dose computerized tomography (LDCT) to be the best method, but have not identified the population at highest risk. This study sought the percentage of lung cancer patients that would have been excluded by USPSTF criteria.

Method: A retrospective chart review identified 170past and present smokers who had undergone lung cancer resection at Hackensack Meridian Health (HMH) hospitals between September 15, 2014 and 2016. Data was collected from the Society of Thoracic Surgeons database. Descriptive statistics and Wilcoxon Rank-Sum tests were used to analyze differences between included and excluded patients.

Results: The percentage of patients that would have been excluded by screening criteria was 46.5% (95% CI: 38.8-54.3%). The difference between ages of included and excluded patients was not quite significant (p=0.051), with only17.1% (95% CI: 11.7-23.6%) of all patients excluded by age. Pack-years of included patients were significantly higher than of the excluded (p<0.001), and 25.3% (95% CI: 18.9-32.6%) had insufficient pack years. Quit-time was also a significant variable (p<0.001) and excluded 37.9% (95% CI: 29.1-49.4%) of past smokers. The percentage included by USPSTF criteria increased from 53.5% to 59.4% when quit-time was set to 25 years, and61.2% when extended to 30 years.

Conclusion: USPSTF criteria would have excluded almost half of the ever-smokers with surgically resectable lung cancers. Age would not have excluded a significant percentage, but inclusion criteria should account for smokers with less than 30 pack-years or who quit over 15 years ago. Future reviews should examine screening efficacy in larger databases. Prospective studies should investigate correlation between age and smoking history, and look to include secondhand smoking and occupational exposure as risk factors for screening.

Hannah A Lee¹, Asa Dewan MS², Kelly Rubino BSN³, Mila Lachica BA¹,², Arthur A Topilow⁴ and Thomas L Bauer³*


Article Image 1

Role of Pre -Treatment FDG PET Quantitative Parameters in Prognostication of Head and Neck Squamous Cell Carcinoma - A Review

In spite of the good organ preservation strategies available for locally advanced Head and Neck Squamous Cell Carcinoma (HNSCC), failure rates have been reported to be as high as 35-50%. There has been an increasing interest in predicting response to treatment, to aid early intervention and better outcomes. FDG-PET is a standard modality for post treatment evaluation, however it is still under utilized as a pre-treatment investigative modality. Several articles have described quantitative parameters in pre-treatment FDG-PET to prognosticate patients and determine likelihood of response to treatment however they are still not used commonly. This article was a review of the literature available on pre-treatment FDG PET quantitative parameters and their value in predicting failure. A thorough review of literature from MEDLINE and EMBASE was performed on pre treatment quantitative parameters in HNSCC. Metabolic Tumor Volume (MTV) and Total Lesion Glycolysis (TLG) were reliable parameters to predict response to organ preservation therapy, disease free and overall survival. SUVmax was an inconsistent parameter. MTV and TLG may help predict poor response to organ preservation to initiate early surgical salvage or modify therapeutic decisions to optimize clinical outcomes. Routine incorporation into PET reporting may provide additional information over SUVmax alone.

Narayana Subramaniam, Deepak Balasubramanian*, Shanmuga Sundaram P and Samskruthi Murthy 


Article Image 1

Staged Surgery Combined with Chemo Radiation Improves Outcome after Incomplete Removal of Gallbladder Cancer

Introduction: Gallbladder carcinoma is the most frequent tumor of the bile system and has a poor prognosis. The main proportion of tumors diagnosed coincidentally after gallbladder removal for various reasons. In these cases, an incomplete removal of the tumors occurs frequently. The adequate treatment of these patients is still under discussion. We present our experience with different procedures.

Patients and Methods: Between 1990 and 2015, we identified 20 patients which were presented at our University Hospital after incomplete removal of gallbladder cancer (R1, R2, RX) as incidental findings after cholecystectomy. The prospectively collected data including surgery, adjuvant treatment, histopathological examinations of the specimens and follow-up data were analyzed retrospectively.

Results: The median age of patients was 72 years (range 47-89 years), 90 % (18/20) were female. The median follow-up period was 10 months (range 0-109 months). The median survival of all patients was 11 months (95 % confidence interval: 5-17 months). The median survival of patients who received staged surgery and chemo radiation after incomplete gallbladder removal was significantly increased (median 32 months; range 4-109 months) vs. patients who received chemo radiation without surgery (median 13 months; range 8-51 months) or chemotherapy alone (median 2.5 months (range 0-40 months)) (p = 0.005).

Discussion: There is no standardized treatment for residual tumor after incomplete gallbladder cancer resection. Our data demonstrate that staged surgery with prior chemo radiation may improve patient´s outcome. Surgery can be performed with low morbidity and mortality.

Marc Daniels¹, Maximilian Brunner¹, Sabine Semrau², Robert Grützmann¹ and Roland S Croner¹*


Article Image 1

Limb Salvage in Patients with Unresectable Recurrent Melanoma and Sarcoma with the Hyperthermic Isolated Limb Perfusion Technique

Introduction: Hyperthermic Isolated Limb Perfusion (HILP) is a surgical procedure for the regional delivery of heat and high doses of chemotherapy and biologic agents to the extremity. The procedure is employed as a limb salvage technique for locally advanced primary malignancies or recurrent cancers that are unresectable and confined to the extremity

Methods: From 1987-2016, 247 patients with unresectable recurrent melanoma (95%), sarcoma or Merkel Cell Carcinoma underwent HILP for limb salvage of the affected extremity after staging was negative for Stage IV disease and disease was confirmed to be confined to the extremity.

Results: All patients had limb salvage with this protocol. All patients were clinically negative in their regional basin at the time of perfusion, although 40% of the patients had evidence of regional nodal disease following nodal dissections. Immediate responses (within 3 months) on the extremity to the HILP were as follows: complete response (CR) of 66%, partial response (PR) of 20%, 10% stable disease and 4% progressive disease. With a mean follow-up period of 5 years, 61.5% of the patients have recurred with 68.4% of the recurrences being systemic, 21% regional nodal, 7.2% in-transit and 3.3% local-regional soft tissue.

Conclusions: HILP is an effective strategy for limb salvage in patients with unresectable, locally advanced cancers confined to the extremity. The treatment was associated with a high rate of complete responses on the extremity. Most patients recurred with distant metastases emphasizing the need for better systemic therapies for these malignancies.

Synopsis: Patients with recurrent, unresectable melanoma, other cutaneous malignancies and sarcoma confined to an extremity are problematic for clinicians since recurrence rates show that most will have occult systemic disease. An aggressive amputation approach does not make sense and the fact that these patients have active disease makes them ineligible for approved adjuvant therapies. In addition since their clinically apparent active disease is confined to the local/regional soft tissues making them Stage 3 disease, they are not eligible for Stage IV protocols. In these situations Hyperthermic Isolated Limb Perfusion (HILP) effectively treats the extremity with high response rates and a 100% limb salvage rate.

Lauren Kerivan, Michael Reintgen, Eric Reintgen, Steve Shivers and Douglas Reintgen* 


Article Image 1

Self-related Quality of Life and Functional Results after Internal and External Hemipelvectomy in 82 Musculoskeletal Pelvic Tumours

Background and purpose: Wide resection in pelvis delivers important drawbacks not only physically but also mentally lowering the functional status and self-related quality of life (SRQL) of these patients. Our aim is to show functional results and SRQL in patients with wide resections in pelvis due to musculoskeletal tumours.

Patients and Methods: It is a retrospective study in patients with wide resections in pelvis due to musculoskeletal tumours and we focus on: demographical data, preoperative and pathology studies, type of resection and reconstruction, functional results (MSTS score) and SRQL (SF-12). We have performed 15 external hemipelvectomies (EH), 57 internal hemipelvectomies with pelvic ring stability reconstruction (IHPR), 10 internal hemipelvectomies without reconstruction of the pelvic stability (IHWR). There were 10 patients with soft tissue sarcomas and benign but aggressive tumours that we do not include in the study as they did not need hemipelvectomy.

Results: We found there is a tendency to better functional results in IHPR, though it shows no statistical differences between the three types of reconstruction. According to SRQL we observed light score loss in mental status related to general population. On the other hand, physical status showed strong score deviation from general population. Functional results seem to be similar to literature.

Interpretation: The severe loss of function and physical status in these patients underline the type reconstruction and avoiding complications as critical steps. The light score deviation in mental status may represent an adaptive pattern and social support of patients with this severe disease and its complications.

Pérez-Muñoz Israel*


Article Image 1

Alveolar Soft Part Sarcoma: Case Report of a Rare Tumor and Review of Literature

Alveolar soft part sarcoma (ASPS) is a rare neoplasm occurring most frequently in the soft tissues of both children and adults, which has a tendency for an indolent course and late metastasis. It is characterized by an unbalanced translocation, der(17)t(X:17)(p11;p25), producing a fusion protein which has recently been shown to play a role in promoting cell proliferation and angiogenesis and may provide a potential target for molecular therapy. We present a case of ASPS and discuss the histology, diagnostic considerations, cytogenetics, treatment, and prognosis.

Glyn Hinnenkamp*, Amy Hackett, Brandon Grodman, Logan Primeaux , Ashley Green, Savannah Sadaiappen , Sylvester Bote, and Mohamed Aziz 


Article Image 1

Secondary primary common bile duct neuroendocrine tumor 10 years after the diagnosis of rectal adenocarcinoma: A case report

Development of a second primary cancer in patients under follow-up because of metastasis is rare. We presented a 58-year-old man with neuroendocrine cancer of vater ampulla and distal common bile duct as a second primary cancer. The patient had been diagnosed with rectal adenocarcinoma and lung metastasis who underwent total mesorectal excision, lung lobectomy, and adjuvant therapy with an interval of 5 years. This article emphasizes on the importance of early detection of second primary cancer and treating it as the primary one

Saba Ebrahimian MD, Sakineh Soleimani Varaki MD 


Article Image 1

Metastatic Chordoma to the lung. Case Report of a Rare Tumor and Brief Review of the Literature

Chordomas are rare, malignant bone tumors with a typically unfavorable prognosis that develop slowly and aggressively along the skull base and axial skeleton from remnants of the primitive notochord. Grossly, chordomas classically present as lobular nodules with thick fibrous tissue; histologically, those fibrous tissues can be seen separating chords of tumor cells in a myxoid stroma. Its characteristic local aggressiveness and indolent growth makes timely detection difficult and local recurrence likely, especially since surgical resection and radiation are the only affective treatment options. Local recurrence currently serves as a significant predictor of metastatic progression which most commonly involves the lungs, liver, bone, and lymph nodes. We report a case of metastatic chordoma to the lung, and discuss the diagnostic features, differential diagnosis, molecular changes, treatment, and prognosis.

Bryan Neal*, Sidney Nathan, Adam Hebert, Clifford Davis, Jodie Simelda, Anthony Dean, Gevork Seifert, Mohamed Aziz